Behr-Bonz 64 in development!

[eslapion]

The problem is it is subjective to each user. So you are going to get a different list each time ...

Yeah but if a couple of different people give me some feedback, like you just did and I appreciate, then its more or less possible to come to a consensus.

Added edit:
I will go against your suggestion and keep Attack of the Mutant Camels as Mayhem rates it as one of the best games.

[Zippy Zapp]

Thats cool. AMC, got it now. I thought that was something else.

[eslapion]

I also see in the list Number Nabber/Shape Grabber and Learning with Leeper.

I think these should also go out.

I remember Frogger II 3-deep as a relatively good game and it is rated quite high by Mayhem as well so I won't follow your advice on this one and keep it.

There is also a Star Wars from Parker Bros. and another one from Atari; which one is the best?

Finally, unlike you, Yaztromo recommends I keep Toy Bizarre and it is also highyl rated by Mayhem.

[eslapion]

List so far:

Code: Select all

4th_sarcophagus.crt       adventure_creator.crt     aegean_voyage.crt         
alien_sidestep.crt        amazing_maze.crt          AMC_US.crt
astroblitz.crt            Avenger.crt               battlezone.crt
BCsQFTrs.crt              Beamridr.crt              Blueprnt.crt
BRIDGE64.CRT              bubble_burst.crt          BuckRgrs.crt
castle_hassle.crt         Centipde.crt              checkers.crt
choplifter.crt            close_encounters.crt      Clowns.crt
cngobngo.CRT              coccinelle.crt            cosmic_life.crt
CrsisMtn.crt              Decathln.crt              defender.crt
delta_drawing.crt         designers_pencil.crt      diamond_mine.crt
dig_dug.crt               DonkyKng.crt              dot_gobbler.crt
dot_gobbler2.crt          dragonsd.crt              espial.crt
facemaker.crt             falconian_invaders.crt    fats_pool.crt
frogger.crt               Frogger2.crt              galaxian.crt
galaxion_munchman.crt
gatewata.crt              GORF.CRT                  gridrunner.crt
Gyruss.crt                HERO.crt                  howzat.crt
ISOCCER.CRT               jackatta.crt              jawbreaker.crt
JBond007.crt              JmpmanJR.crt              juice.crt
jukebox.crt               jumpman_junior.crt        JunglHnt.crt
jupiterl.crt              KICKMAN.CRT               kindercomp.crt
laser_cycles.crt          LAZARIAN.CRT              lazerzone.crt
learning_leeper.crt       lemans.crt                LodeRnnr.crt
lunar_leeper.crt          marios_brewery.crt        mastertype.crt
mazeman.crt               maze_master.crt           miner_2049er.crt
mole_attack.crt           money_wars.crt            MoonPtrl.crt
moon_dust.crt             motor_mania.crt           mountain_king.crt
mrcool.crt                mrtnt.crt                 MsPacMan.crt
music_composer.crt        music_machine.crt         mutant_spiders.crt
novablast.crt             oils_well.crt
omega_race.crt            pac-man.crt               paint_brush.crt
pastfinder.crt            pinball_spectacular.crt   pipes.crt
Pitfall.crt               Pitfall2.crt              pitstop.crt
PolePstn.crt              Popeye.crt                princess_frog.crt
q-bert.crt                rack_em_up.crt            radar_rat_race.crt
retro_ball.crt            RivrRaid.crt              road_race.crt
rootin_tootin.crt         Rtrn2084.crt
sammy_lightfoot.crt       save_new_york.crt         Seafox.crt
sea_wolf.crt              Serpntne.crt              skeleton.crt
solar_fox.crt             space_action.crt          space_ricoshay.crt
space_shuttle.crt         speedbingo_math.crt       spitball.crt
spy_hunter.crt            starpost.crt              star_ranger.crt
star_trek.crt             star_wars.crt             star_wars_(atari).crt
stix.crt                  story_machine.crt         supersma.crt
super_alien.crt           tank_wars.crt             tapper.crt
the_pit.crt               threshold.crt             tooth_invaders.crt
ToyBzrre.crt              trashman.crt              turbo_mazeman.crt
tylers_dungeons.crt       ultrex_quadro_maze.crt    up_for_grabs.crt
up_n_down.crt             wizard_of_wor.crt         Zenji.crt

[yaztromo]

List is looking fab. I am up for one of these.

[fuzzybad]

Here's my opinion on the ones to remove. I'm starting with the 3 you mention, then I list carts that I find to be total crap and/or boring, and finally there are a few I have never heard of. Presumably, if these were any good I would have heard of them before.

1 checkers.crt
2 speedbingo_math.crt
3 sviduzzles.crt
4 NmbrNabr.crt
5 facemaker.crt
6 fraction_fever.crt
7 music_composer.crt
8 threshold.crt
9 money_wars.crt
10 designers_pencil.crt
11 kindercomp.crt
12 BRIDGE64.CRT
13 alf_color_caves.crt
14 story_machine.crt
15 alphabet_zoo.crt
16 adventure_creator.crt
17 delta_drawing.crt
18 super_alien.crt
19 tylers_dungeons.crt
20 fats_pool.crt
21 mrtnt.crt
22 falconian_invaders.crt
23 coccinelle.crt
24 aegean_voyage.crt
25 4th_sarcophagus.crt

Note: You appear to have Jumpman Jr listed twice, which gives a starting point of 151 files. Also, there are dot_gobbler.crt and dot_gobbler2.crt, which might be the same.

[eslapion]

Following your advice I now have:

1.alien_sidestep.crt
2.amazing_maze.crt
3.AMC_US.crt
4.astroblitz.crt
5.Avenger.crt
6.battlezone.crt
7.BCsQFTrs.crt
8.Beamridr.crt
9.Blueprnt.crt
10bubble_burst.crt
11.BuckRgrs.crt
12.castle_hassle.crt
13.Centipde.crt
14.checkers.crt
15.choplifter.crt
16.close_encounters.crt
17.Clowns.crt
18.cngobngo.CRT
19.cosmic_life.crt
20.CrsisMtn.crt
21.Decathln.crt
22.defender.crt
23.diamond_mine.crt
24.dig_dug.crt
25.DonkyKng.crt
26.dot_gobbler.crt
27.dragonsd.crt
28.espial.crt
29.frogger.crt
30.Frogger2.crt
31.galaxian.crt
32.galaxion_munchman.crt
33.gatewata.crt
34.GORF.CRT
35.gridrunner.crt
36.Gyruss.crt
37.HERO.crt
38.howzat.crt
39.ISOCCER.CRT
40.jackatta.crt
41.jawbreaker.crt
42.JBond007.crt
43.juice.crt
44.jukebox.crt
45.jumpman_junior.crt
46.JunglHnt.crt
47.jupiterl.crt
48.KICKMAN.CRT
49.laser_cycles.crt
50.LAZARIAN.CRT
51.lazerzone.crt
52.lemans.crt
53.LodeRnnr.crt
54.lunar_leeper.crt
55.marios_brewery.crt
56.mastertype.crt
57.mazeman.crt
58.maze_master.crt
59.miner_2049er.crt
60.mole_attack.crt
61.money_wars.crt
62.MoonPtrl.crt
63.moon_dust.crt
64.motor_mania.crt
65.mountain_king.crt
66.mrcool.crt
67.MsPacMan.crt
68.music_machine.crt
69.mutant_spiders.crt
70.novablast.crt
71.oils_well.crt
72.omega_race.crt
73.pac-man.crt
74.paint_brush.crt
75.pastfinder.crt
76.pinball_spectacular.crt
77.pipes.crt
78.Pitfall.crt
79.Pitfall2.crt
80.pitstop.crt
81.PolePstn.crt
82.Popeye.crt
83.princess_frog.crt
84.q-bert.crt
85.rack_em_up.crt
86.radar_rat_race.crt
87.retro_ball.crt
88.RivrRaid.crt
89.road_race.crt
90.rootin_tootin.crt
91.Rtrn2084.crt
92.sammy_lightfoot.crt
93.save_new_york.crt
94.Seafox.crt
95.sea_wolf.crt
96.Serpntne.crt
97.skeleton.crt
98.solar_fox.crt
99.space_action.crt
100.space_ricoshay.crt
101.space_shuttle.crt
102.spitball.crt
103.spy_hunter.crt
104.starpost.crt
105.star_ranger.crt
106.star_trek.crt
107.star_wars.crt
108.star_wars_(atari).crt
109.stix.crt
110.supersma.crt
111.tank_wars.crt
112.tapper.crt
113.the_pit.crt
114.threshold.crt
115.tooth_invaders.crt
116.ToyBzrre.crt
117.trashman.crt
118.turbo_mazeman.crt
119.ultrex_quadro_maze.crt
120.up_for_grabs.crt
121.up_n_down.crt
122.wizard_of_wor.crt
123.Zenji.crt

I have Star Wars from 2 different companies and I am missing 4 games. I kept Threshold as I remember it being a more or less decent game.

Any other suggestion that would fit the 8k/16k limitation?

[MitchFrenzal]

Bit late, But the Parker bros star wars is awful, The other one should be Domark, not atari.

[eslapion]

@MitchFrenzal
Looking at Mayhem's cartridge scans and the Star Wars from Parker Bros. has a rating of 7 which is pretty good.

Also, Domark never made a game called Star Wars in cartridge form.

[fuzzybad]

Good call on Threshold. It's not that bad, personally I just find it lackluster. I'm sure there are carts which are much more deserving to be cut..